So right out of the gate, Kamala has chosen to avoid the question “are you better off today than before?”
Sadly, Trump failed to poke her on that. He did correct her on the Tariff vs Sales Tax.
Her rebuttal was just an attack, but was weak. Lacked substance.
His rebuttal was decent.
Her rebuttal was, again, lacking substance and weak. “no plan for you!”
“She doesn’t have a plan”.
Tariffs: Nice. “Not gonna have higher prices” …”my tariffs still exist…if they thought they were bad, why did they keep them?” “They destroyed the economy”
“Trade Deficit”. she has no answer, she only has an attack. (I find this sad, I expected better from her, to be honest) “Lets talk about this” is starting to grate.
“They bought their chips from Taiwan”…”We hardly make chips here because of the Democrat policies.” .Heh. Policies and called her a Marxist. Immigration Bad policies destroyed our economy. Pretty good response
Abortion rights: 9 Months. That is a hard hit. Nice that he mentioned Ronald Reagan. (Of course, the moderator had to use her position to do her best to discredit him on abortion)
Kamala is using emotion to tug at women’s hearts about abortion. sad, no real substance. At least she took a position for once.
Good, he points out that it is now the state’s choice, not the feds. “I will not do a national abortion ban.” Of course, he is prevaricating on “Would you veto a national abortion ban”
Of course, she brings up IVF treatments. Nice way of mixing that with abortion.. But she keeps falling back to slogans.
I like the fact that he took the firm position and demanded the chance to respond. I also like the fact that he made her obviously fail to respond to his question about abortion. That was telling.
Border security: A hard question. She is doing her best to not answer the question. She blames Trump for the failure to secure the border. Nice, Fail. Rallies are not part of the question. Fall back to the slogans….”He doesn’t care about you”.
Trump is getting angry though. Frustrated. Looks bad. I think she struck a nerve about the rallies.
“Extreme” …she is doing her best to make him angry. It is working. Attacks but no substance, but it is getting under his skin.
“i fired those people” Nice rebuttal to those who she used as examples. “I fired him and then he wrote a book”
Immigration: Deportation. 11 Million undocumented. How will you find them and deport them? “Destroying the fabric of our country”
Ah. Yes. “Prosecuted” ….nice diversion. Fail to answer on immigration or deportation. Glaringly obvious that that was a prepped response. Sad.
Trump is getting angry.
Harris is using her chance to answer to pontificate and tell us what she thinks Trump will do…She isn’t answering her question.
Hard question for Harris: Asking why she is flipflopping. ::Why have your policies and beliefs changed?: She danced and fell back to “I was raised a poor child” …failed to answer. It appears all she has is slogans.
Trump scored big “Excuse me, I am talking now: Sound Familiar?” But at the end, he is, again looking rattled.
Jan 6th. “Anything you regret” “I said Peacefully and patriotically”. Nice Ashley Babbit? Nice.” When are the people that burned down Minneapolis gonna be prosecuted.?”
“Incited a violent mob” This one will harm him. She used Charlottesville narrative to stab him. Nice use of the Democrat narrative rather than the truth, but it was a telling blow.
“Falsely claimed you won” Nice. “We need walls and good elections” And the moderator is losing his appearance of impartiality Nice rebuttal by Trump re: vote fraud.
And this question for Harris was as partial as it gets. Leading, and presumptive statement. Trump should have called him out on that.
Trump’s response is a decent one….”This weak pathetic man”.
Another hard question to Harris. “How would you break through the stalemate with Hamas and Israel?” “How Israel defends itself matter”….But she doesn’t answer the question. Nice dancing. She must think she needs both the Palestinian votes and the Israeli votes. But her answer likely pissed everyone off.
“She hates Israel” 2 years until Israel disappears. “Iran had no money for terror when I was president.” “I will get the Ukraine war stopped”
Harris goes to the :”It is well known” trope. Attacks but no real substance. “They can manipulate you”. Trump should have asked her to name ONE person one leader who said that. Make her call someone out.
At the break she seems nervous,…He seems angry and unsettled. I fear his ego will cause him to lose it.
Ukraine: “I wanna save lives” “We are in for 250 Billion. where is Europe?” “I will get it settled before I am even president if I am elect” “Never would have started if I were president.” “Where is Biden”
Harris: Nice “you aren’t running against Biden, you are running against me”. I met with Zelensky. I net with NATO”.
“Quiet please” That was telling. “She was the emissary and she failed”
Fall back to a prepared statement. She knew that the question was gonna be asked and how and that was a prepared statement.
Afghanistan: Do you believe you bear any responsibility? No answer, af=gain, a prepared statement. “Does not understand the role and responsibility ofthe president of the United States” Invited the Taliban,
“I sent him a picture of his house” :That’s why Russia attacked Ukraine, because they knew she was how incompetent”
“I don’t care if she is black”
Harris: “attempts to use race to divide the American People” Funny that. Then proceeds to do just that. Hypocrite.
Trump is flailing in his answer here.
“Believes what is possible” “Let’s talk about our plans” Like “hope and change” only relabeled.
Trump is losing it.
Obamacare: “We are working on it”. “Do you have a plan to replace it?” “I tried to fix it, it still will never be great” But then he failed :”We have the concept of a plan” That was a bad response.
Harris: ‘What is your plan today?” She sidesteps. Attacks Trump, but doesn’t answer the question as to how to fix Obamacare”? “access to healthcare should be a right”
Climate change: What would you do? Harris: “Not a hoax” “Invested in clean energy. But not an answer on climate change.
Trump: you didn’t create manufacturing jobs, you sent them to other countries. Biden is bought by China and Ukraine” Actually a good statement.
Break time.
Of course they let Harris go first in the closing statement. “Chart a New Way forward….Have a Plan. Opportunity economy…..Lots of slogans. :cares about you, a president for all Americans”
Trump “Why hasn’t she done it? They’ve had 3-1/2 years….Why didn’t you do it? We are a nation in decline….What these people have done to our country. The worst in the history of our country”
At the end of it, I don’t think either did a decent job. Harris failed to look presidential, and failed to show why she should be chosen. She did get Trump a bit angry. It showed.
Trump had some good points, but in the end, he failed to strike a killing blow, and failed to make her look bad. Despite the obvious bias of the moderators, he didn’t fail too badly.
I doubt that this debate helped either side. No clear winner. I strongly doubt that either candidate swayed anyone enough to change a vote or win aby converts.
It was interesting that the questions were carefully tailored to avoid the real issues that could have harmed Harris.. It really looked to me that Harris had the questions, or at least the substance of the questions, beforehand.
Interesting that the post debate folks are doing their best to discredit him. Lots of fail there too. The bias is obvious, b ut I doubt if anyone is really listening. The governor of Pennsylvania (on NBG)as a surrogate for the Harris campaign is doing his best to do damage control for Harris, but he is such an obvious hack that he looks bad.
Having said that, I think we are so screwed.